Omnibus prik

OPINION: Artificial Intelligence is a systematic illusion of intelligence

We are told that the humanities must deliver ‘solutions’. The processes of the humanities are essential to the ‘solutions’ that we can provide. Having them simulated by algorithms misses the point entirely, writes professor of English literature, Dominic Rainsford.

Dominic Rainsford is professor of Literature in English at the School of Communication and Culture at Aarhus University. Foto: Private

Deltag i debatten

Omnibus bringer gerne debatindlæg skrevet af universitetets studerende og medarbejdere.

Hold det under 4.000 anslag inkl. mellemrum. 

Send dit indlæg til omnibus@au.dk

Læs mere om debat i Omnibus 

Dette er et debatindlæg, synspunterne i indlægget er udtryk for skribentens holdning. 

I welcome Dean Maja Horst’s acknowledgement that Artificial Intelligence is not the same for everyone. But I’m concerned at the normalisation of the very term ‘Artificial Intelligence’, referring to commercial productivity software based on Large Language Models. What is at issue is a systematic illusion of intelligence: an amalgamation of existing knowledge so vast that we can no longer see where it came from. What bothers me more, however, is the lack of detail about how LLMs have already impacted disciplines such as mine.

COLUMN: Artificial intelligence is transforming all of our subjects, but not necessarily in the same way

I've had my words stolen

As an author, I have had my words stolen. I am one of many who were told, last year, that their books had been harvested by Anthropic as food for LLMs. I took part in a lawsuit which was decided in our favour. I will not refuse the few hundred dollars that will eventually come my way, but I know that this is just a drop in Anthropic’s budgetary ocean, a small price that they are happy to pay, so that they can carry on doing what they do.

An LLM doing its amoral best

I am also the editor of Dickens Quarterly. Last year I received a prospective article. The topic seemed suitable. Looking at the ‘Works Cited’, I saw familiar names. But suddenly it struck me that I had overlooked almost everything that they had written. Then I understood: these were texts that real scholars might have written, had their aim been to support the article’s thesis. I then checked the quotations from Dickens. I did not recognise any of them. They had a Victorian flavour, but were not remotely on Dickens’s level. Again, they were attempts at the words that Dickens might have provided, if his purpose had been to support the article. So it was obvious: an LLM had done its amoral best; it had no concept of truth or falsehood, only a puppy-like devotion to its current user. In its own vast-but-tiny non-mind it was just trying to help.

Student papers free from errors

As a teacher, I have found that most student papers are now free from basic errors. All of the typical problems with subject-verb agreement, for example, have disappeared, virtually overnight. It’s a miracle! How have they learned so much, so quickly? Many papers correspond immaculately to a raw formula of thesis statement–methodology–examples–analysis–conclusion, in headed sub-sections of two or three sentences, repetitive and without personality. It’s nothing like the way of addressing literature that I was trained in, and that defines my teaching. There are still students who read, think, and write for themselves, and don’t want commercial software to take this from them. But it becomes harder to resist the temptation, or even realise what is happening, within an educational context that values results rather over process, exams over learning, and generic skills over specific knowledge.

Processes simulated by algorithms

We are told that the humanities must deliver ‘solutions’. Well, insofar as we can help stop the climate disaster or prevent Armageddon, let’s do it! But what the ‘traditional’ humanities offer is immersion, reflection, memory, self-development, knowledge of real others in real times and places, articulated independent thought, a questioning relation to society, and the maintenance of a shared cultural heritage. These things really may help prevent Armageddon – if anything can – by maintaining concepts of human value. The processes of the humanities, in other words, are essential to the ‘solutions’ that we can provide. Having them simulated by algorithms misses the point entirely.

This is personal

Finally: the personal element. My identity is utterly bound up with language. When ‘Copilot’ offers to modify my sentences – or did, until I scorched its invasive code out of my Office installation – I feel physically sick. How dare you interfere in my thinking and voice? How dare you reduce me to your vision of post-literacy: a world of the cognitively inadequate, for whom composing sentences is simply too hard? How dare you treat me as a customer who can be tricked into thinking that you are a real ‘intelligence’? This is emotional. But then … I’m human.