Omnibus prik

There is little evidence of state outsourcing leading to lasting savings

Outsourcing public-sector cleaning services can bring financial and administrative benefits for employers, but Danish research suggests any savings are far from guaranteed, and employees may bear much of the cost.

Ole Helby Petersen is a professor at Roskilde University, a visiting professor at the University of Oxford and one of Denmark's leading researchers in public outsourcing. He also heads the Centre for Research on Public-Private Collaboration, which collaborates with a number of universities across Europe and the United States. Photo: Roskilde University

As Omnibus has previously reported, the administration at Arts is considering outsourcing cleaning services in the faculty’s buildings in Emdrup, home to parts of the Danish School of Education (DPU). The prospect of a private company being responsible for the cleaning in the future is causing concern among the department's staff - both among scientific and technical-administrative staff and, of course, among the cleaning staff.

But what conclusions can researchers draw about the pros and cons of letting a private company take over a task currently carried out by a public-sector employer such as Aarhus University?

Omnibus has spoken to Ole Helby Petersen about this. He is a professor at Roskilde University, a visiting professor at the University of Oxford and one of Denmark's leading researchers in public outsourcing. He also heads the Centre for Research on Public-Private Collaboration, which collaborates with a number of universities across Europe and the United States.

As a professor at Roskilde University, he has long played a central role in research on this subject, drawing on Danish data and statistics. In 2023, he was appointed editor-in-chief of the Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, widely regarded as one of the most prestigious journals in the field of public administration. He also led the EffektDoku project, which examined the consequences of outsourcing.

“We have evidence showing that outsourcing technical services, such as cleaning, from a public-sector employer to a private provider typically generates savings of between 5 and 10 per cent. We also have extensive evidence showing that employees whose work is outsourced pay a large part of the price when services are transferred from the public to the private sector,” says Ole Helby Petersen. 

That is the overarching conclusion supported by a body of research conducted by Ole Helby Petersen and his colleagues over the years. Their findings cover several aspects of the outsourcing process, including its financial implications, its impact on service quality, and the consequences for employees who move from public- to private-sector employment as a result of outsourcing.

Ole Helby Petersen stresses that he has no basis to comment on the specific situation involving the possible outsourcing of cleaning services in Emdrup. He is solely speaking about the findings that research in the field has produced so far regarding the consequences of public tendering and outsourcing more generally.

Why outsource?

The process of assessing a defined service and then putting it out to competitive tender is intended to ensure that the service is delivered in the best and most cost-effective way possible.

“In the past, many public-sector employees had less incentive to carry out their work in the most effective and cost-efficient way. In some places, this resulted in inefficiency and wasted tax money. Outsourcing is a way of challenging a monopoly," says Ole Helby Petersen.

Some public-sector services are more suitable for outsourcing. According to Ole Helby Petersen, this means that technical services such as cleaning or canteen operation are often first on the list when public institutions look for opportunities to outsource.

“The complexity of a task is a crucial factor in determining whether it makes sense to outsource it. Can the task be described clearly and precisely, and is it possible to verify that the service being provided is the one that was agreed and paid for? This is possible for many of the technical services," explains Ole Helby Petersen.

What does research say?

To assess the advantages and disadvantages of outsourcing, Ole Helby Petersen refers to three different studies in particular, that each examine the consequences of public outsourcing in a different way. 

Main conclusions of the research

Put simply, the findings of research into public-sector outsourcing can, on the basis of these three studies, be summarized as a set of advantages and disadvantages of outsourcing:

Possible advantages:

Lower costs, because competition can help drive prices down.

Increased productivity, because private suppliers have an incentive to organise the work more efficiently.

Higher specialisation, because a private supplier may have special skills and systems.

Organisational flexibility, because the public institution can pay for a cleaning service rather than having to run the organisation itself.

Less direct responsibility for staff, as the private supplier takes on the role of employer.

More predictable expenses, as an agreement is easier to budget for.

Possible disadvantages:

Savings may be limited and can be reduced by the costs of tendering and contract management.

Any productivity gains may stem from reduced working hours, increased work intensity, or lower wage costs.

The research does not have evidence to suggest that private cleaning is generally of higher quality.

The public institution takes on new responsibilities such as contract management, monitoring, and follow-ups.

Employees risk a drop in income and fewer hours of work.

Changing needs can result in additional services and extra expenses.

One of the studies is a research article in which Ole Helby Petersen and his colleagues conduct a systematic review of all relevant Danish and international research to examine whether outsourcing public services leads to cost savings and improved service quality.

"It very often turns out that it is difficult to document the actual savings. Employers often expect savings of around 20 to 30 per cent. What we can say based on the international literature is that the savings are typically between five and 10 percent. But that is still a considerable saving, and one that is certainly worth acknowledging,” says Ole Helby Petersen.

Another conclusion is that the financial gains from outsourcing have diminished significantly over time, and that there is no scientific evidence to support the general assumption that a private provider is more efficient than a public one.

The fact that savings have decreased over time may be due to the fact that public employers have already streamlined their own workflows.

The article also points out that the true costs associated with outsourcing remain insufficiently understood.

“It is often poorly documented what the situation actually looked like before outsourcing took place, making it difficult to determine whether the many additional benefits and costs have been adequately accounted for in the overall calculation. In some cases, the pre-outsourcing situation is based on assumptions or estimates because there is no comprehensive record of what the outsourced task actually cost when it was previously carried out in-house,” says Ole Helby Petersen.

Employees pay

In another research article published in 2022, the researchers use register data to show that outsourcing has negative financial consequences for employees who move from public-sector to private-sector employment. They generally experience a loss of income. At the same time, the study shows that part of the cost is effectively transferred to the public sector, as expenditure on transfer income increases for these employees. Compared with the control group, they are more likely to lose their jobs and therefore require support funded by taxpayers.

“It is a very large-scale study, which indicates that employees experience a loss of earnings following outsourcing. Some of this is due to employees being laid off, while others have their working hours reduced. It is not necessarily the hourly pay that declines, but overall their income falls significantly following a transfer of operations from the public to the private sector,” concludes Ole Helby Petersen.

The researchers followed 1,478 employees who were transferred from a public to a private-sector employer in connection with 73 outsourcing operations in the period from 2005 to 2013. 

The study shows that cleaning assistants in particular are hit hard. 87 per cent of the employees included in the study worked in cleaning.

The three studies

The three studies Ole Helby Petersen refers to are: 

'Is Contracting out of Public Services still the Great Panacea?'– 2018: A systematic review of 49 international studies from 2000-2014. The savings generated by outsourcing have diminished over time and vary more widely across individual service areas and countries. Often, the studies do not measure quality and indirect costs sufficiently.

'Competition, Ownership, and the Impact of Government Outsourcing on Employees' - 2022: A Danish register-based study of 1,478 outsourced employees. The researchers found declines in both earnings and employment, alongside an increase in public transfer payments. The effect on the use of healthcare services is limited and temporary. 

'The Unequal Distribution of Consequences of Contracting Out' – 2023: A Danish register-based study in which the main analysis includes 390 outsourced employees. The study finds that the consequences of public-sector outsourcing are distributed unevenly across social groups. Women, those with a low level of education, and young people are hit hardest. 

The study also shows that the examined private-sector collective agreements set work intensity at an index of 130, compared with an index of 100 in the public-sector agreements included in the study. In practice, this means that the cleaning assistants have to work faster.

"Specifically, this means that a private employer can demand 30 per cent higher productivity," says Ole Helby Petersen.

An incomplete picture

In the third study, the researchers find that it is especially low-skilled women who are hit hardest by outsourcing. Over time, they experience the greatest loss of earnings, as they tend to lose more working hours than their male colleagues.

The study also puts a figure on the additional costs the public sector has to bear as a consequence of outsourcing. Following outsourcing, the affected employees received almost 40 per cent more in public transfer income than the control group after one year. Two years after the transfer to a private employer, the difference had increased to more than 50 per cent.

After five years, there is no longer any measurable difference between the outsourced employees and the control group.

“Overall, we can see that around half of the losses experienced by outsourced employees are covered by public transfer payments. That cost is rarely taken into account when a public-sector employer assesses the potential savings from outsourcing,” says Ole Helby Petersen.

And according to the researchers, the fact that a wide range of costs, as well as benefits beyond the purely financial ones, are not taken into account is one of the main problems when trying to answer the question of what the consequences of public-sector outsourcing actually are.

“Public-sector employers have a responsibility to safeguard taxpayers’ money. Therefore, services can be outsourced if it is economically advantageous for the state. However, when those calculations are made, they are carried out only at the level of the individual institution, without taking into account the associated costs borne by other parts of the state,” concludes Ole Helby Petersen. 

This text is machine translated and post-edited by Mie Skov Jeppesen.