The quality of Master’s theses has fallen as a result of the study progress reform

Less time for in-depth study and reflection, more superficial analyses and less scope for learning. These are some of the criticisms expressed by thesis supervisors at Aarhus BSS in a survey performed by the Centre for Teaching and Learning commissioned by the Aarhus BSS Academic Council. 27% of the experienced supervisors who participated in the survey agreed that the quality of Master’s theses has declined since the introduction of the study progress reform.

Translation: Indicate whether you perceive the Master’s theses being handed in as academically weaker or stronger compared with previously. In general, the Master’s theses are academically weaker. The Master’s theses are neither weaker nor stronger. In general, the Master’s theses are academically stronger. Source: Quality in Master’s theses, quality survey 2018 (in Danish)

As a result of the reform, students now have four and a half months to write their theses instead of six. And that has consequences.

Fifty-six percent of the supervisors advise students against choosing ‘risky’ Master’s theses projects more often than previously, while 32 percent encourage students to work with theories and methods they are already familiar with more often.

Translation: Supervisors’ strategies for supervision, post-study progress reform: Tell the students which theories and methods I think they should use. Recommend to students that they use theories and methods they have previous experience with. Make sure that the students have a viable research question early on. Require that students submit draft text prior to meetings. Follow the students’ progress closely. Give very concrete advice on the best thing to do. Set milestones and tell the students what they need to accomplish. Help students break their tasks into easily manageable subtasks. Advise the students against doing risky projects. Talk with students about their level of ambition for the Master’s thesis. Tell students to be honest if they are having difficulty with something. Much less or somewhat less. Neither more nor less. More or much more. Source: Quality in Master’s theses, quality survey 2018 (in Danish)

On five of Aarhus BSs’ ten degree Master’s degree programmes, the requirement for the length of the thesis has been reduced, and about one in four supervisors finds that fewer theses are based on independent empirical observation, while one in five finds that fewer students write their theses in collaboration with external partners such as private companies and public institutions.

Translation: Indicate the extent to which the Master’s theses you supervise or assess are based on material the student has collected on his her her own as compared to previously. Are to a lesser extent based on empirical data gathered by the student on his or her own. Are neither to a greater nor a lesser extent based on empirical data gathered by the student on his or her own. Are to a greater extent based on empirical data gathered by the student on his or her own. Source: Quality in Master’s theses, quality survey 2018 (in Danish)

Translation: Indicate whether your students collaborate with private companies or public sector organisations as part of the Master’s thesis to a lesser or greater extent than previously. Collaborate with private companies or public sector organisations to a lesser extent. Collaborate with private companies or public sector organisations neither to a lesser nor greater extent. Collaborate with private companies or public sector organisations to a greater extent. Source: Quality in Master’s theses, quality survey 2018 (in Danish)

This is not a crisis

While Per Andersen, vice-dean for education at Aarhus BSS, takes the researchers’ perception of a decline in quality seriously, he also notes that there has been no marked fall in the grades awarded to Master’s theses since the reform.

“It’s still the same learning objectives and the same supervision, and the result is still about the same grades as before. Objectively speaking, there’s nothing that indicates that the theses are weaker. On the other hand, when over a third of the supervisors share this perception, we have to look at how we can address the situation so that they don’t continue to have that perception,” says Andersen.

However, he stresses that he doesn’t see the situation as a crisis.

“Most of the students finish within the prescribed time to degree and with a good result. Generally speaking, we have gotten through the first phase of implementing the reform successfully.”

The survey also shows that students complete their degrees more quickly, and that the supervisors perceive students as better at managing the thesis process, which is also more clearly defined and framed, according to the supervisors.

Search for solutions after the summer holiday

Andersen does not have any concrete solutions in the works, but will discuss the issue with the directors of studies and the staff of the individual degree programs after the summer holiday.

“There’s a lot of variation in what kind of theses we have for the different degree programs. It can’t be a one-size-fits-all solutions, but rather measures which are tailored to the individual degree programs. I would rather spend time finding good solutions than on finding quick solutions.”

Precisely for this reason, students who are set to write their Master’s theses in the course of the next year shouldn’t count on any major changes in the process.

Not enough time to assess theses

The decline in the quality of Master’s thesis is not the only problem identified by the supervisors at Aarhus BSS. Over half of them find that there the conditions for thesis supervision have changed for the worse, among other reasons because there is too little time to assess them. Andersen intends to address this issue as well after the summer holiday.

Translation: Indicate whether you think that the conditions under which you supervise Master’s theses have improved, remain unchanged or have worsened as compared to previously. The conditions have worsened, generally speaking. The conditions have neither worsened nor improved. The conditions have improved, generally speaking. Source: Quality in Master’s theses, quality survey 2018 (in Danish)

Translated by Lenore Messick