Omnibus prik

Professor admits error: "I am deeply sorry"

It was a terrible day for the handful of researchers in Foulum who, after years of work calculating nitrogen emissions, had to concede that an error had been discovered despite numerous checks and double-checks. But that does not mean there is now reason to doubt all the calculations, nor that the foundations of the new nitrogen regulation are crumbling, says Professor Jørgen Eriksen.

Jørgen Eriksen is a professor and section manager at the Department of Agroecology at Aarhus University. He is also project manager for the work on the NUAR calculator, which produces the calculations that form the basis of the nitrogen regulation. Photo: Jens Hartmann Schmidt, AU Photo

For decades, a group of researchers has worked diligently to develop a calculator that estimates nitrogen emissions from agriculture. Millions of data points. Dataset after dataset. Calculation after calculation. Again and again, in their efforts to fulfil the task set by the government. 

“It's really exciting, and at the same time it has great importance for a lot of people. Both for those who make a living from agriculture, who deserve proper treatment, and for all those who want better water quality," says Jørgen Eriksen, who is a professor and section manager at the Department of Agroecology at Aarhus University. He is also project manager for the work on the NUAR calculator, which produces the calculations that form the basis of the nitrogen regulation.

What is NUAR?

NUAR stands for New Emissions-Based Land Regulation and is a calculation tool that will be used in the new nitrogen regulation in 2027. NUAR does not determine the farmer's quota, but provides part of the basis for calculation. Environmental goals, reduction requirements and specific regulations are set by policymakers.

The model calculates – it does not measure – how much nitrogen is released from individual fields, and draws on information about soil type, climate, runoff, crops, fertiliser application and other factors.

NUAR has been developed by the Department of Agroecology at Aarhus University in collaboration with the University of Copenhagen and others. The project was commissioned and funded by what was then the Danish Agricultural Agency.

Source: DCA – Danish Centre for Food and Agriculture  (In Danish, ed.)

In recent months, politicians’ demands to improve water quality in Danish coastal waters by requiring reductions in agricultural nitrogen emissions have sparked heated debate. Both among politicians, who want to see results after years of evidence showing that water quality is steadily declining. But also among farmers, who feel that they are fighting against a system that threatens their families and their very existence.

AU research criticised in political conflict

“We are under great pressure from many sides. The social relevance is a great motivation for many of those who work with this. No one became a researcher to sit behind a desk and write long reports. We want to benefit society and contribute to its development,” says Jørgen Eriksen.

The one thing that was not supposed to happen

When SEGES, an independent research and innovation company involved in developing the new nitrogen regulations, questioned the so-called set-aside measure last week, Jørgen Eriksen and his team were asked to revisit the calculations.

Then, the one thing that wasn’t supposed to happen, happened. SEGES was right. There was an error in the calculations.

“During a triple-check of the datasets, the researchers identified a technical error in the way livestock manure had been factored into the calculations, confirming what SEGES had last week assessed to be an error in the model,” stated the press release issued by Aarhus University late on Tuesday evening.

Project manager Jørgen Eriksen spent all of Wednesday being “deeply sorry” and taking full responsibility for the fact that an error had been made in the calculations for which he was responsible. 

“What we are working with is extremely complex. We work with datasets containing over four million data points. We provide research-based science advice to the authorities, and this is always of great societal importance. Therefore society should be able to rely on us to handle complex issues.  We do that every day, but in this case we have made a mistake, and we apologize for that,” says Jørgen Eriksen, who does not hide the fact that the situation has hit hard among the handful of staff involved in the calculations.

“It was absolutely horrible and incredibly irritating. Producing accurate and reliable calculations is what we live and breathe, which is why this is so upsetting.  Wednesday was a really tough day, but there is nothing else to do but acknowledge the error and correct it as quickly as possible,” says Jørgen Eriksen.

The set-aside measure

The error made by the researchers relates to the set-aside measure.

“It is an important figure, because it determines the maximum reduction required of farmers and therefore has a major impact on their businesses. If the set-aside measure is too low, farmers may find it difficult to meet the reduction target decided by politicians. And if the set-aside measure is too high, the required reduction will not be achieved,” explains Jørgen Eriksen.

He also explains that the error relates solely to the dataset for spring barley with catch crops and affects only areas where livestock manure is used extensively.

A month ago, farmers demonstrated outside Christiansborg as politicians passed the Fertiliser Act, which is intended to regulate nitrogen emissions from agriculture. Meanwhile, a convoy of tractors drove through the University Park in protest against the work carried out by Aarhus University.

At the time, Brian Vinter, vice-dean at the Faculty of Technical Sciences, where the work on the NUAR calculator is based, maintained in numerous media interviews and on national television that there was nothing wrong with Aarhus University’s calculations.

“That was based on all the calculations we had carried out up to 1 September,” says Jørgen Eriksen.

According to Jørgen Eriksen, the calculations carried out by the researchers over the summer incorporated a number of new elements requested by the Danish Agency for Green Land Transformation and Aquatic Environment (SGAV). Jørgen Eriksen also explains that many of the new elements had a far greater impact on the set-aside measure than the spring barley datasets, meaning the error went unnoticed.

“This is not an attempt to make excuses. It is simply the explanation. We alone are responsible for ensuring that the figures are correct. We have not delivered as we should have, and we deeply regret that. I would like to apologize to the board and to all affected stakeholders," says Jørgen Eriksen.

A single error

When news of the error in the calculations and the set-aside measure broke on Wednesday, several media outlets presented it as proof that farmers had been right all along in claiming that Aarhus University’s calculations were far too uncertain to be used as a basis for regulating agricultural nitrogen emissions.

Jørgen Eriksen firmly rejects that claim.

“That’s not the case. It's not as though the entire foundation underpinning our calculations is crumbling. This error can have a major impact on individual farmers, and people have to live with the consequences of the calculations we make. I have great respect for that, but we are talking about a single error,” says Jørgen Eriksen, before continuing:

“The error is very specific, and we are happy that it has been found. Our only ambition is to deliver accurate results, which is why it is important that we are open about it and acknowledge our mistakes when they occur. Partly so that we can correct the error, but also to ensure that people can trust what we say.”

Noble intentions

It is still too early to know how large the error is or how many farmers have been affected. But if Jørgen Eriksen were to imagine the worst-case scenario, the error could mean that some farmers in areas where a lot of manure is used may have been given a set-aside measure that is 10 percent too low.

The figure remains subject to all the usual caveats until the calculations have been rerun, but according to Jørgen Eriksen, the 10 per cent figure gives a sense of the scale of the issue.

Jørgen Eriksen acknowledges that the calculations produced by his team have a major impact on farmers across Denmark. But he also stresses that it is politicians who set the nitrogen-reduction targets, while the NUAR calculator was developed to help farmers meet those targets in the most flexible way possible.

“There are many big challenges that farmers are struggling with right now. We are trying to create a tool that helps individual farmers comply with the new rules and achieve the required reductions in nitrogen emissions. But it also means that they experience different outcomes in the calculations,” says Jørgen Eriksen.

No guarantees but a promise

Throughout Wednesday, Jørgen Eriksen was repeatedly asked whether he could guarantee that no further errors would be made. Each time, his answer was the same as the one he gave Omnibus.

“Of course, I cannot guarantee that mistakes will not happen. But I can promise that we do everything in our power, every single day, to avoid mistakes.”

The researchers will now return to the model and run the dataset for spring barley with catch crops and livestock manure application through the NUAR calculator once again.

“There are already people working through the calculations as we speak. We should have a result within a couple of weeks, and I can assure you that those results will be subjected to extensive quality checks before they are released,” says Jørgen Eriksen.

This text is machine translated and post-edited by Mie Skov Jeppesen.